Holiday Fraud Trends 2026:

Fake Online Stores & Purchase Scams

Scammers Get Paid Twice. Stop Them at the Merchant.

Black Friday, Cyber Monday, and the weeks after bring surges in transactions, first-time merchants, and promotional ads, and scammers often use that volume to blend in. Fake online stores may accept real card payments for goods that never ship. The scammers can then steal shoppers’ card data and sell it on the dark web. In the year leading up to this season, more than 102 million stolen cards were posted for sale, and 73% of them belonged to US and Canadian cardholders.*

Scammers often treat fake stores as disposable and use AI-enabled tools to replace them as fast as they are taken down. The asset they protect is the merchant account behind the stores. From April through September 2026, Recorded Future identified 2,000 scam merchants accepting payments on 3,000 fake stores, and 47% of those merchants took payments across multiple stores.

This report from Recorded Future’s Payment Fraud Intelligence team breaks down how scammers can lure shoppers, onboard as merchants, and steal card data through fake stores and e-skimming. It also gives card issuers, acquirers, and shoppers practical recommendations to help cut off scam merchants and limit downstream fraud.

Want the researchers’ walkthrough? Register for the webinar to hear how fraud teams can respond during the holiday peak.

*Recorded Future® Payment Fraud Intelligence: Stolen Payment Card Data